In this analysis, I will explore the representation of beauty and ugliness in Scott Westerfeld's novel Uglies (2005), and how language is used to set up our modern world of comparison and perfectionism as the most dreadful dystopia. The novel asks readers to assess whether the world would be a better place if we were all the same, and what effect monoculturalism has if the image of acceptability is singular and naturally unattainable.
As a part of Year 8's differentiated novel study unit on dystopian literature this term, some of the students opted to read Scott Westerfeld's novel Uglies (2005). While my class of 60 students chose to cover other books, I was intrigued to explore this novel myself. In the world of the novel, everyone without full body cosmetic surgery is considered ugly, and must wait until they are sixteen years old to undergo 'the operation' that will make them 'a pretty'. Uglies all live in Uglyville (where everyone is apparently "ugly" and "vile"), and are plagued with deep self loafing as they await their surgery, which will allow them to start a life of frivolity and luxury in New Pretty Town. There is however more to the story, and a price that must be paid for this initiation into this apparent utopia.
To some extent, we have all been in the position of looking at ourselves in the mirror and not being happy with what we see, especially when we do not see ourselves as favourably represented in the media. When something goes wrong, rather than asking "why me?" and "what have I done to deserve this?", after being conditioned in a society that thrives on feelings of inadequacy and never being enough, the brain can get into the habit of turning all questioning inward, and unproductively demand to know if:
Am I not pretty enough?
Is my heart too broken?
Do I cry too much?
Am I too outspoken?
Don't I make you laugh?
Should I try it harder?
Why do you see right through me?
- Not Pretty Enough by Kasey Chambers (2001)
As a child in the early 2000s, I idolised Lindsay Lohan, the Olsen Twins, Paris Hilton, and Mischa Barton. As I grew up, my perception of not only beauty, but success, happiness, and power were informed by what I saw on television, in films, and printed on the glossy pages of Harper's Bazaar magazine. While it is a rational and factual reality that people who look and act differently gain what they are looking for in life, falling down the rabbit hole of "why do I look like this, when they look like that?" becomes almost inevitable to a point, especially when the image of what is good and socially acceptable is so singular and often reinforced in everything you see and hear.
In the novel, the bright allure of New Pretty Town and the promise of conformity is powdered with doubt from the very first sentence. The novel opens with "The early summer sky was the colour of cat vomit". The metaphor highlights that there is something physically repulsive, disgusting and perhaps overindulgent about the swirling pink sunset, a sight which would usually be very pleasing to most. The image is extended as our protagonist Tally considers that "...you'd have to feed your cat only salmon-flavoured cat food for a while, to get the pinks right. The scudding clouds did look a bit fishy, rippled into scales by a high altitude wind" (p. 3). An interesting detail that one may not immediately pick up is that of the metaphorical cat food being "salmon-flavoured", rather than just salmon. This points to the artificiality of the world of the novel, and that not everything is as it seems. The clouds that are described to literally look "fishy" are also an example of pathetic fallacy, as the physical elements of the landscape are mirroring the fishiness of the setting which our protagonist faces. As Tally gazes towards New Pretty Town, "...snakes of burning torches marked flickering pathways through the pleasure gardens" (p. 3). While the town looks perfect to Tally Youngblood, a young-blooded and impressionable teenager on the brink of maturity, the Biblical allusion to the snake in the Garden of Eden warns the reader of the evil temptations that are present in this apparent haven. As a reader, Tally's glimpse into New Pretty Town from Uglyville is similar to a regular person opening a magazine, or scrolling through a model's Instagram page. In these instances, what may appear spontaneously perfect has been carefully constructed, edited, and selected with strategical precision. While many people know this as a fact, it is hard to see the cracks in the image when you are not only the targeted audience, but the 'captured' audience in that moment. As a result, it can be easy to unknowingly develop tunnel vision like Tally, and only see what we are allowed to see. Thus, the blur between perception and reality is marked as a key concern early in the story.
In dystopian fiction, the society that is presented may seem to be not only functional but also ideal upon first inspection.Through reading, the responder as well as Tally must be shaken awake and out of the dream set up by a lifetime of social conditioning. Like any typical ugly, Tally is looking forward to her surgery. This is made apparent to reader by her repeatedly counting down the time to her birthday, from "...three months and two days"(p.3) at the start of the novel to "...two months and twenty-six days" (p. 37) when she meets Shay, a fellow ugly who shares her birthday, but not her views about the operation. While Tally likes to sneak out after curfew and spy on the pretties in New Pretty Town, Shay plays "ugly tricks" like this not out of envy of others, but to enjoy being different and being free to have fun. According to Shay, being pretty makes you "Pretty and boring...[as]....Doing what you're supposed to do is always boring. I can't image anything worse than being required to have fun" (p. 49). Tally's thinking around the New Pretty Town being a joyful place is directly challenged by the idea that fun is something you have to do, rather than something you are free to have. Thus, the seemingly carefree society is revealed to be a facade as it only looks that way because people have to make it look like that. Foreshadowing is used to warn the readers about the pretties when Shay makes the joke "All that glitters is not hovery" (p. 60). With the fake word "hovery", Shay explains in a lighthearted manner how the hoverboards work best over iron rather than gold. In this moment, Shay references the well known idiom 'all that glitters is not gold', in order to warn Tally and the reader to look beyond initial appearances, and not to be taken in and dazzled by something that looks beautiful, as 'beautiful' is not always synonymous with 'good'.
In a less subtle way, Shay also attempts to challenge Tally by describing the operation in a way Tally had "never heard" before, "...when they do the operation - when they grind and stretch your bones to the right shape, peel off your face and rub all your skin away, and stick in plastic cheekbones so you look like everybody else - may after going through all that you just aren't very interesting anymore" (p. 50). In this moment, Tally physically flinches. This shows the reader her automatic bodily reaction to this harsh description of reality. While her mind has been conditioned to accept the surgery as normal and good, her actions speak louder than words, as in her body she knows something is not right. In quiet thought, Tally remembers that "Even in bio class, where they went into the details, it didn't sound that bad". This moment highlights that social conditioning has infiltrated the education system, and that the agenda of this dystopian world is being taught and presented as facts of life to the citizens from a young age. Tally then attempts to dismiss Shay's claims by saying that they "...won't even know what's happening. You just have pretty dreams the whole time". This dialogue comes across as someone else's words, as if she is quoting the biology teacher. Here, Tally's actions show her cognitive dissonance, a state that "...occurs when a person's behaviors and beliefs do not align. It may also happen when a person holds two beliefs that contradict one another. Cognitive dissonance causes feelings of unease and tension, and people attempt to relieve this discomfort in different ways"(Leonard, 2019). While Tally can tell that something is certainly off in the world she is living in, she is wanting to keep her eyes closed to the reality of the situation. In instances of cognitive dissonance, facing the fact that what has always been known to be true is not as is seems is painful, thus it is more comfortable to reject anything that conflicts with these beliefs. In Uglies, Tally is not only indoctrinated by the leaders of this world, but also desperately wants what she has been taught to be true, as the possibility of it being a lie is far too painful to conceive.
With purposeful language choices, Westerfeld makes a strong case against social monoculturalism as the answer to inequality. In order to gain a clear perspective, it is essential in the case of Tally to distance herself from the closed world of Uglyville and New Pretty Town. According to YourDictionary, 'monoculture' can be defined as being "A single, homogeneous culture without diversity or dissension...A group, society, etc. characterized by cultural uniformity" or "The cultivation of a single crop on a farm or in a region or country...The raising of only one crop or product without using the land for other purposes"(YourDictionary, 2022). In a social context, the idea presents that sameness is the answer to issues around inequality. In the world of Uglies, every citizen goes through the same educational system, and waits until they are sixteen to get the operation, which allows them to enter the same seemingly utopian society. In theory, everyone is on the same playing field. Lois Lowry in her novel The Giver (1993) played with a similar idea around sameness, where it also meant for the people in that society to see in black and white, and be without emotion. In Chapter 12, the Giver tells the protagonist Jonas that "Our people made that choice, the choice to go to Sameness. Before my time, before the previous time, back and back and back. We relinquished color when we relinquished sunshine and did away with difference. We gained control of many things. But we had to let go of others." In a sense, the world of The Giver appears to be ideal. Without colour, there is no racism. Without choice around jobs and vocation, people do not need to fight for job security. Without love, there is no heartbreak. Much like in the Uglies however, cracks form as inherent hypocrisies within the system are revealed.
By using the agricultural meaning of monoculture, the book makes a point to reveal the destructive power of sameness. As Tally enters the territory near the camp of runaways known as The Smoke, she comes across a group of men who are spreading fires across the landscape to "...save the world, kid" (p. 180). According to these 'rangers', around 300 years ago the "phragmipedium panthera" or "white tiger orchid" had been genetically engineered to grow and spread easily, as "...a single bulb was worth more than a house...[now] there's zillions of them". The hyperbole highlights the extent to which the flowers now blanket the field. Tally questions why it is a problem, as "They're nice". Here, Tally continues to equate beauty with goodness. The ranger replies saying that it is "One of the most beautiful plants in the world...They turned into the ultimate weed. What we call a monoculture. They crowd out every other species, choke trees and grass...". He goes on to explain that that lack of trees caused the hummingbirds that spread their seed to move away "So the orchids eventually die out, victims of their own success, leaving a wasteland behind. Biological zero" (p. 182). The orchids can be seen as an extended metaphor for the pretties. Much like how agricultural monoculture can lead to the destruction of all plants in an area, the plan to make everyone exactly the same may be to the detriment of the human race. If we were all the same and all 'perfect', nothing would change and improve. If what was perfect was a set standard, we would never learn about others and gain a wider world view outside of our immediate surroundings. In agriculture and in society, isolation is shown to be deadly. In response, Tally thinks that "The flowers were so beautiful, so delicate and unthreatening, but they choked everything around them" (p. 183). The juxtaposition between the gentle appearance and deadly nature of the orchids highlights that appearances can be deceiving, and also emphasises the great extent to which Tally has been conditioned to take things at face value.
In conclusion, Scott Westerfeld's novel Uglies makes a clear distinction between beauty and ugliness by making only one look beautiful, and every other possible appearance 'ugly'. The importance of looks becomes more than a surface issue, as everyone in the world of the novel are conditioned to judge the character and value of a person on their appearances. This becomes the main method of societal control as no one is able to look 'pretty' naturally, and without the intervention of government workers. This makes every citizen at the mercy of the whims of the leaders, as it is up to them to make it possible for people to live a good life and be accepted and regarded well by others. With distinctive language choices, Westerfeld shows how a modern world of comparison and perfectionism can be the most dreadful dystopia; a world of loneliness and self hatred. Within this system, non-conformists are not only shunned by each other, but due to their conditioning have no peace within themselves either, as physical appearance has been made not only the most important thing, but a signifier of someone's worth. Through exploring the idea of monoculturalism, readers can see the destructive power of sameness, and the psychological damage could occur if the image of acceptability is singular and naturally unattainable by most if not all people.
Books:
Lowry, L. (2014). The Giver. HarperCollins.
Westerfield, S. (2005). Uglies. Simon Pulse.
Websites:
Leonard, J., (2019). 'Cognitive dissonance: What to know'. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/326738
Not Pretty Enough Lyrics. (n.d.). Lyrics.com. Retrieved June 28, 2022, from https://www.lyrics.com/lyric/5222660/Kasey+Chambers/Not+Pretty+Enough.
YourDictionary, (2022). 'Monoculture Definition'. https://www.yourdictionary.com/monoculture
Videos:
Kaseychamberstv. 2009, Kasey Chambers - Not Pretty Enough (Official Video), online video, viewed on 29 June 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5rOdF9rUKI
Tate McRae. 2022, Tate McRae - she's all i wanna be (Official Video), online video, viewed on 29 June 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uS_y_65CcpA